Text or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260

Tax Law

Estate of Powell v. Commissioner (2017): FLP and section 2036

Section 2036(a) may include transferred property in the gross estate if the decedent retained, for life or a specified period that does not end before death, possession or enjoyment, the right to income, or the right to designate who may possess or enjoy the property or its income. It excepts bona fide sales for adequate and full consideration.

This page is general research, not tax, legal, or investment advice. Do not take any action based on this page without first consulting a qualified CPA or tax attorney who knows your facts.

Case facts2017

Key statutory figures

FigureTax year or exact effective datePinpoint cite
20 percent of total combined voting powerMeasured during the 3-year period ending on the date of the decedent's deathIRC § 2036(b)(2)
Transfers before March 4, 1931Date stated in the provisionIRC § 2036(c)
Transfers after March 3, 1931, and before June 7, 1932Dates stated in the provisionIRC § 2036(c)

Section 2036(a): transfers with retained interests

Section 2036(a) generally includes in the gross estate the value of property the decedent transferred if the decedent retained certain rights. The statute covers rights retained for life or for a specified period that does not end before death. The retained rights it lists fall into three groups:

  • Possession or enjoyment of the transferred property
  • The right to income from the property
  • The right, alone or with another person, to designate who may possess or enjoy the property or its income

A transfer alone does not trigger the rule. The rule concerns a transfer combined with a retained interest of the kind described. Whether a particular arrangement involves such an interest depends on its facts.

The bona fide sale exception

Section 2036(a) excepts transfers made in “a bona fide sale for an adequate and full consideration in money or money's worth.” The transfer must be bona fide, and the consideration must be adequate and full.

Readers should not assume that a particular transfer, including a transfer to an FLP, meets the exception. That determination depends on facts and authorities beyond the statute's wording.

Section 2036(b): voting rights in a controlled corporation

Section 2036(b)(1) adds a specific rule for corporate stock. For purposes of section 2036(a)(1), retaining the right to vote shares of a controlled corporation, directly or indirectly, is treated as retaining enjoyment of the transferred property.

Section 2036(b)(2) defines a controlled corporation by reference to the 3-year period ending on the date of the decedent's death. During that period, the decedent must have owned, applying section 318, or had the right to vote stock with at least 20 percent of the total combined voting power.

Section 2036(b)(3): relinquishing voting rights

Section 2036(b)(3) links section 2036(b)(1) to section 2035. When section 2035 is applied to section 2036(b)(1), relinquishment or cessation of voting rights is treated as a transfer of property made by the decedent.

Section 2036(c): early transfers

Section 2036(c) states that the section does not apply to transfers made before March 4, 1931. It also sets a separate rule for transfers made after March 3, 1931, and before June 7, 1932. These are historical limits, not current-year deadlines.

Amendment history

Editorial notes accompanying the statute state that a 1990 amendment redesignated former subsection (d) as subsection (c) and struck former subsection (c). The notes describe the removed provision, which is not current law.

Hypothetical example

Hypothetical example. The following is illustrative only. It is not drawn from Powell, an official example, or a real taxpayer.

Assume the statutory conditions described in section 2036(b)(2) are met.

  • Because 25 percent is at least 20 percent, the corporation may be a controlled corporation under section 2036(b)(2).
  • Under section 2036(b)(1), the retained right to vote the transferred shares may be treated as retained enjoyment for purposes of section 2036(a)(1).
  • For purposes of applying section 2035 to section 2036(b)(1), section 2036(b)(3) treats relinquishment or cessation of voting rights as a transfer of property made by the decedent.

Whether any amount is actually included in the gross estate depends on the full facts, the bona fide sale exception, attribution under section 318, and other provisions and authorities. The example does not predict a result.

Questions to take to a CPA or tax attorney

The following questions are discussion prompts, not recommendations.

  1. What does the full text of Estate of Powell v. Commissioner say, and which parts of section 2036 did the court address?
  2. What is the current status of the decision, and have later authorities followed, limited, or distinguished it?
  3. In my facts, did the transferor keep any right described in section 2036(a), such as possession, enjoyment, income, or the right to designate who benefits?
  4. How do the “bona fide” and “adequate and full consideration” requirements apply to the transfers in my situation, and what evidence bears on each?
  5. Does any corporation in my family's holdings meet the 20 percent voting-power test in section 2036(b)(2) during the relevant 3-year period, once section 318 attribution is applied?
  6. If a voting right is relinquished, how does section 2036(b)(3) interact with section 2035, and what time periods apply?
  7. If a structure is meant to reduce or defer transfer tax, which statutory provisions and authorities beyond section 2036 also need review?
  8. What documentation and records would a qualified professional want to see before forming a view on gross estate inclusion?

This page is general research, not tax, legal, or investment advice. Do not take any action based on this page without first consulting a qualified CPA or tax attorney who knows your facts.

Sources

  1. IRC section 2036(a), transfers with retained life estate and the bona fide sale exception. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/2036
  2. IRC section 2036(b)(1), retained voting rights in a controlled corporation treated as retained enjoyment. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/2036
  3. IRC section 2036(b)(2), controlled corporation definition and 20 percent of total combined voting power during the 3-year period ending on the date of death. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/2036
  4. IRC section 2036(b)(3), relinquishment or cessation of voting rights treated as a transfer for purposes of section 2035. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/2036
  5. IRC section 2036(c), limitation for transfers before March 4, 1931, and rule for transfers after March 3, 1931, and before June 7, 1932. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/2036
  6. IRC section 2036, Editorial Notes, Amendments (1990), redesignation of former subsection (d) as subsection (c) and removal of former subsection (c). https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/2036