Soroban Capital Partners v. Commissioner (2023): limited partners and SE tax
In Soroban Capital Partners v. Commissioner, the Tax Court held that the self-employment tax exclusion for a limited partner's distributive share does not apply merely because a partner is called a limited partner. It may apply to a partner functioning as a limited partner, based on a functional analysis of the partner's role (161 T.C. at 316, 319-21).
This page is general research, not tax, legal, or investment advice. Do not take any action based on this page without first consulting a qualified CPA or tax attorney who knows your facts.
Case facts2023
Key dates and scope
The opinion was filed November 28, 2023, and covers tax years 2016 and 2017. It does not decide the final self-employment tax result for Soroban's partners.
| Item | Date or tax year | Pinpoint cite |
|---|---|---|
| Opinion filed | November 28, 2023 | 161 T.C. at 310 |
| Tax years at issue | Tax years 2016 and 2017 | 161 T.C. at 310-12 |
| TEFRA procedures, as described in the opinion | Applied only to tax years beginning before January 1, 2018 | 161 T.C. at 311 n.1 |
| Final or temporary regulations defining "limited partner" under § 1402(a)(13) | None issued as of the opinion date, November 28, 2023, according to the opinion | 161 T.C. at 318 |
The statutory question
A partner's distributive share of partnership income can count toward net earnings from self-employment, which is generally the base for self-employment tax. IRC § 1402(a)(13) contains an exclusion. It removes from net earnings from self-employment a limited partner's distributive share of partnership income or loss, except for qualifying guaranteed payments for services actually rendered (161 T.C. at 316).
The statute refers to a "limited partner, as such." The question in Soroban was what that phrase means. One reading is that any partner who holds a limited partner interest under state partnership law qualifies. The other reading is that the exclusion depends on what the partner actually does in the business.
The opinion also notes that, as of its filing on November 28, 2023, Treasury had not issued final or temporary regulations defining "limited partner" for this purpose (161 T.C. at 318). This is a statement in the 2023 opinion. It speaks only as of the opinion date and does not reflect current guidance.
Procedural posture
Soroban arose as a set of partnership-level proceedings under TEFRA for tax years 2016 and 2017 (161 T.C. at 310-12). Both sides filed motions. The petitioner moved for summary judgment. The Commissioner moved for partial summary judgment.
The court denied the petitioner's motion and granted the Commissioner's motion for partial summary judgment (161 T.C. at 325). The court said the background facts in the opinion were stated only to decide those motions. They were not findings of fact (161 T.C. at 312-13).
This posture matters. The opinion settles legal and jurisdictional questions. It does not settle how those rules apply to the specific individuals at Soroban.
What the court held
The opinion's holdings fall into three parts.
1. The exclusion turns on function, not title
The court held that the § 1402(a)(13) exception does not apply just because a partner is called a limited partner. It applies to a partner who is functioning as a limited partner (161 T.C. at 316, 320-21). A state-law label, without more, did not decide the issue.
2. A functional analysis is required
To decide whether a partner in a state-law limited partnership is a "limited partner, as such," the court required a functional analysis of the partner's functions and role (161 T.C. at 319, 325).
3. The inquiry is a partnership item under TEFRA
For a partnership subject to TEFRA, the court held that the functional inquiry is a partnership item. Its reasoning was that the inquiry involves factual determinations underlying the partnership's aggregate net earnings from self-employment. As a result, the Tax Court may decide that inquiry in a TEFRA partnership-level proceeding (161 T.C. at 322-25).
What the court did not decide
Readers sometimes take more from a summary judgment opinion than it actually holds. Soroban has clear limits.
- No finding on Soroban's partners. The opinion does not decide whether Soroban's limited partners were, in fact, limited partners "as such." It also does not decide whether their distributive shares were ultimately subject to self-employment tax. The motions resolved legal and jurisdictional questions only (161 T.C. at 312-13, 325).
- No blanket rule for state-law limited partners. The opinion does not say that every state-law limited partner owes self-employment tax on distributive income. It requires a functional analysis, and the outcome of that analysis depends on the facts.
- No ruling on later tax years under TEFRA. The opinion describes TEFRA as applying only to tax years beginning before January 1, 2018 (161 T.C. at 311 n.1). The TEFRA jurisdiction holding should not be read as applying TEFRA to tax years beginning on or after that date.
TEFRA context
TEFRA was the set of partnership audit and litigation procedures in effect for the years at issue. According to the opinion, those procedures were repealed and applied only to tax years beginning before January 1, 2018 (161 T.C. at 311 n.1).
Soroban's tax years 2016 and 2017 fell within that window. The partnership-item holding is therefore tied to the TEFRA framework.
Current-status notes
This page discusses the 2023 Tax Court opinion itself. It does not address:
- whether the decision was appealed, or the result of any appeal
- the opinion's later precedential treatment
- any later court decisions, regulations, or administrative guidance that may modify or interpret it
Readers studying this area may want to ask a qualified professional whether later developments affect the analysis for a given tax year.
Hypothetical example
This is a hypothetical example for illustration only. It is not drawn from the opinion and does not predict any outcome.
An investment management business is organized as a state-law limited partnership. Several individuals hold limited partner interests under the partnership agreement. Those individuals also work in the business day to day. They make investment decisions, manage staff, and represent the firm to clients.
Before Soroban, the partnership's advisers may have treated the state-law label as the main fact in reporting the distributive shares under § 1402(a)(13). Under the court's reasoning for tax years 2016 and 2017, the label alone does not decide the question. A functional analysis of each partner's role would be required (161 T.C. at 319-21, 325).
If the partnership were subject to TEFRA for a tax year beginning before January 1, 2018, the opinion indicates that the functional inquiry would be a partnership item that the Tax Court may decide at the partnership level (161 T.C. at 311 n.1, 322-25).
Questions to raise with a CPA or tax attorney
These questions may help organize a conversation with a qualified professional. They are not recommendations.
- For each tax year at issue, does the partnership's reporting under § 1402(a)(13) depend mainly on state-law limited partner status, or on a review of what each partner actually does?
- What facts about a partner's functions and role might be relevant in a functional analysis, and how are they documented?
- Have there been court decisions, appeals, regulations, or IRS guidance after November 28, 2023 that affect how Soroban applies?
- Which partnership audit procedures apply to the tax years in question, given the opinion's statement that TEFRA applied only to tax years beginning before January 1, 2018?
- Do any payments to partners count as guaranteed payments for services actually rendered, and how does the statutory exception treat them?
- How might the partnership agreement, governance documents, and day-to-day practice affect a functional review?
- What procedural options and exposures might exist if a functional inquiry is raised for an open tax year?
This page is general research, not tax, legal, or investment advice. Do not take any action based on this page without first consulting a qualified CPA or tax attorney who knows your facts.
Sources
- Soroban Capital Partners LP v. Commissioner, 161 T.C. (opinion filed November 28, 2023), United States Tax Court.
- Tax years 2016 and 2017, motions, and disposition: 161 T.C. at 310-12, 325.
- TEFRA repeal and applicability to tax years beginning before January 1, 2018: 161 T.C. at 311 n.1.
- Background facts stated only for deciding the motions: 161 T.C. at 312-13.
- Scope of the § 1402(a)(13) exception: 161 T.C. at 316, 320-21.
- No final or temporary regulations defining "limited partner" as of the opinion: 161 T.C. at 318.
- Functional analysis requirement: 161 T.C. at 319, 325.
- Functional inquiry as a partnership item under TEFRA: 161 T.C. at 322-25.
- Official opinion: https://ustaxcourt.gov/files/documents/161_TC_112-328.pdf
- Alternate text: https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9582156/soroban-capital-partners-lp-v-commissioner/
- Internal Revenue Code § 1402(a)(13), as discussed in 161 T.C. at 316.