Rev. Rul. 59-60: valuing closely held stock
Rev. Rul. 59-60 generally guides how closely held stock may be valued for estate and gift tax purposes. It treats fair market value as a question of fact, determined as of the required appraisal date, and sets out eight nonexclusive factors that may be weighed based on the circumstances. It offers no formula (Rev. Rul. 59-60, Sec. 3.01).
This page is general research, not tax, legal, or investment advice. Do not take any action based on this page without first consulting a qualified CPA or tax attorney who knows your facts.
Case facts
What the ruling addresses
Rev. Rul. 59-60, 1959-1 C.B. 237, covers the valuation of stock in closely held corporations. It also covers stock whose market quotations are unavailable or too scarce to reflect fair market value. The ruling frames its guidance around estate and gift tax purposes (Sec. 1). Depending on the transfer, the required appraisal date may be the date of death, an elected alternate date, or the date of gift (Sec. 2.01).
The ruling states that no general formula can be devised that applies to the many different valuation situations that arise (Sec. 3.01). Instead, it describes a method of analysis and a set of factors that an appraiser would weigh in light of the facts. How it applies to a particular set of facts may vary.
The full text of Rev. Rul. 59-60 is reprinted in Appendix A of an IRS Job Aid dated October 29, 2014. The Job Aid states that it was prepared for reference purposes only, that it is not official IRS position, and that it may not be used or cited as authority for setting a legal position. This page cites the ruling by section number.
The fair market value standard
The ruling defines fair market value by reference to the regulations it cites. Under that definition, fair market value is the price at which property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, "neither being under any compulsion," with both having reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts (Sec. 2.02).
Three further points from the ruling shape how that standard is applied:
- Question of fact. Fair market value depends on the circumstances of each case. A sound valuation considers all relevant facts and applies informed judgment and reasonableness in weighing their significance. The ruling states that valuation is not an exact science (Sec. 3.01).
- Facts known at the appraisal date. A valuation must rest on facts available at the required appraisal date (Sec. 3.03).
- Thin or erratic markets. When stock is closely held, infrequently traded, or traded in an erratic market, the ruling says some other measure of value may be needed. Prices of stock in companies engaged in the same or a similar line of business, actively traded in a free and open market, may serve as a measure (Sec. 3.03).
The eight factors in Section 4.01
Section 4.01 lists eight factors that the ruling describes as fundamental and requiring careful analysis. The ruling states that the list is not all-inclusive.
| Factor | Pinpoint cite |
|---|---|
| Nature of the business and history of the enterprise | Rev. Rul. 59-60, Sec. 4.01 |
| Economic outlook in general and for the specific industry | Rev. Rul. 59-60, Sec. 4.01 |
| Book value of the stock and financial condition of the business | Rev. Rul. 59-60, Sec. 4.01 |
| Earning capacity of the company | Rev. Rul. 59-60, Sec. 4.01 |
| Dividend-paying capacity | Rev. Rul. 59-60, Sec. 4.01 |
| Whether the enterprise has goodwill or other intangible value | Rev. Rul. 59-60, Sec. 4.01 |
| Sales of the stock and size of the block to be valued | Rev. Rul. 59-60, Sec. 4.01 |
| Market price of stock of comparable companies actively traded in a free and open market | Rev. Rul. 59-60, Sec. 4.01 |
Financial history the ruling describes
The ruling describes the financial records an appraiser would ordinarily review. These are guidance on the period of review, not fixed valuation rules.
| Item | Period or date | Pinpoint cite |
|---|---|---|
| Balance sheets for "two or more years immediately preceding" the appraisal date, plus a balance sheet at the end of the month preceding the appraisal date if the corporation's accounting permits | As of the required appraisal date | Rev. Rul. 59-60, Sec. 4.02(c) |
| Profit-and-loss statements for "five or more years" preferred | The period immediately prior to the required appraisal date | Rev. Rul. 59-60, Sec. 4.02(d) |
How the factors are weighted
The ruling states that the weight given to each factor depends on the circumstances and the nature of the business (Sec. 5).
The ruling offers two illustrations of that principle (Sec. 5):
- For companies that sell products or services to the public, earnings may be the most important criterion of value.
- For investment or holding companies, the assets may receive primary consideration.
The ruling also addresses shortcuts. It says that averaging several factors, such as book value, capitalized earnings, and capitalized dividends, and basing value on that result, does not provide a prescribed valuation method because it excludes active consideration of other pertinent factors (Sec. 6). It also states that a standard table of capitalization rates applicable to closely held corporations cannot be formulated (Sec. 7).
Stock sales, block size, and control
Prior sales of the stock are relevant but are not automatically determinative. Under Sec. 4.02(g), the ruling describes these points:
- Sales should be investigated to determine whether they were at arm's length.
- Forced or distress sales do not ordinarily reflect fair market value.
- Isolated sales in small amounts do not necessarily control as the measure of value.
- The size of the block of stock is a relevant factor.
- The presence of actual or effective control of the corporation is a relevant factor.
The ruling also states that past dividends are not automatically a measure of value. Dividend-paying capacity, rather than dividends actually paid, is the listed factor (Secs. 4.01, 4.02(e)).
Restrictive agreements
Closely held stock is often subject to buy-sell agreements or options. Section 8 of the ruling treats these as a factor to be considered with other relevant factors, rather than as a rule that fixes value on its own terms.
- Depending on the circumstances, a bona fide agreement entered into for sound business reasons, binding during life and at death, may or may not fix value for estate tax purposes (Sec. 8).
- When an option or buy-sell agreement is effective only at death, the ruling states that it does not necessarily limit fair market value to the option price (Sec. 8).
Hypothetical example
The following facts are hypothetical. They are not drawn from the ruling and are offered only to show how its framework is organized. No valuation result is implied.
A decedent held a minority block of shares in a family investment company that owns marketable securities and real estate. The decedent also held shares in a separate family company that operates a regional distribution business. Neither stock is publicly traded. Two small sales of the investment company's shares took place between relatives several years before death. A buy-sell agreement covering the operating company's shares becomes effective only at death.
Applying the structure of Rev. Rul. 59-60, an appraiser would likely:
- Measure both blocks as of the required appraisal date (Sec. 2.01).
- Consider whether the investment company's assets merit primary consideration, as the ruling suggests for holding companies, and whether earnings merit greater weight for the operating company (Sec. 5).
- Review the financial history described in Secs. 4.02(c) and 4.02(d) as of the appraisal date.
- Investigate whether the intrafamily sales were at arm's length, and recognize that isolated small sales do not necessarily control (Sec. 4.02(g)).
- Weigh the size of each block and whether it carries actual or effective control (Sec. 4.02(g)).
- Treat the death-only buy-sell agreement as one factor that does not necessarily limit value to the option price (Sec. 8).
- Look for actively traded companies in the same or a similar line of business as a possible measure (Sec. 3.03).
The ruling states that no general formula applies and that no standard table of capitalization rates can be formulated, so the analysis rests on informed judgment applied to these facts (Secs. 3.01, 6, 7).
Related rulings
Rev. Rul. 59-60 states that it superseded Rev. Rul. 54-77 (Sec. 9 and introductory text).
A note in the reprinted text refers to Rev. Rul. 65-192. According to that note, Rev. Rul. 65-192 states that Rev. Rul. 59-60 also applies for other tax purposes and to determining the fair market value of business interests of any type.
Questions to take to a CPA or tax attorney
- What is the required appraisal date for this transfer, and does an alternate date election appear to be available on these facts?
- Which of the eight Section 4.01 factors appear most relevant to this business, and why?
- Is this entity more likely to be viewed as an operating company or as an investment or holding company under Section 5?
- Were any prior sales of the stock at arm's length, and how much weight might they carry under Section 4.02(g)?
- Does the block being valued carry actual or effective control, and how might that affect the analysis?
- How might an existing buy-sell agreement or option be treated under Section 8, given whether it binds during life and at death?
- Are there actively traded companies in the same or a similar line of business that could serve as a measure under Section 3.03?
- What later authorities, including Rev. Rul. 65-192, bear on how this ruling applies today?
- What qualifications should an appraiser have for this engagement?
This page is general research, not tax, legal, or investment advice. Do not take any action based on this page without first consulting a qualified CPA or tax attorney who knows your facts.
Sources
- Rev. Rul. 59-60, 1959-1 C.B. 237, Secs. 1, 2.01, 2.02, 3.01, 3.03, 4.01, 4.02(c), 4.02(d), 4.02(e), 4.02(g), 5, 6, 7, 8, and 9, as reprinted in Appendix A of IRS, S Corporation Valuation Job Aid for IRS Valuation Professionals (October 29, 2014). https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-lbi/S%20Corporation%20Valuation%20Job%20Aid%20for%20IRS%20Valuation%20Professionals.pdf
- IRS, S Corporation Valuation Job Aid for IRS Valuation Professionals (October 29, 2014), disclaimer stating that the Job Aid is not official IRS position and may not be used or cited as authority for setting a legal position. https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-lbi/S%20Corporation%20Valuation%20Job%20Aid%20for%20IRS%20Valuation%20Professionals.pdf