Text or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260

Tax Law

Rev. Rul. 93-12: family-held minority discounts

Rev. Rul. 93-12 holds that, for gift and estate tax valuation of stock in a corporation with a single class of stock, family members' shares are not aggregated with transferred shares to find a controlling interest. A minority discount will not be disallowed solely because of family relationships, though the ruling sets no discount amount. (Rev. Rul. 93-12)

This page is general research, not tax, legal, or investment advice. Do not take any action based on this page without first consulting a qualified CPA or tax attorney who knows your facts.

Case facts

Summary of the ruling

Rev. Rul. 93-12 addresses a narrow valuation question: when a donor transfers shares of a closely held corporation to family members, are shares held by other family members combined with the transferred shares to decide whether the transferred shares carry control?

For a corporation with a single class of stock, the ruling says family members’ shares are not aggregated with the transferred shares for that purpose. The Service states that it will follow Bright, Propstra, Andrews, and Lee on this point. The ruling also revoked Rev. Rul. 81-253.

The ruling does not set a discount percentage or provide a valuation method or formula. Nor does it guarantee that a minority discount will be allowed. It addresses whether family relationship alone permits aggregation or disallowance.

The valuation framework the ruling applies

The ruling’s Law and Analysis section starts with the general gift tax valuation rules.

Amount of the gift. Section 2512(a) provides that the value of property on the date of a gift is treated as the amount of the gift. (Rev. Rul. 93-12, 1993-1 C.B. 202, Law and Analysis, quoting IRC § 2512(a).)

Willing buyer and willing seller. The gift tax regulations describe value as the price at which property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither under compulsion, with both having reasonable knowledge of relevant facts. (Rev. Rul. 93-12, 1993-1 C.B. 202, Law and Analysis, quoting Treas. Reg. § 25.2512-1.)

Stock and degree of control. For stock, the regulations look to fair market value per share on the gift date. Where there are no sales prices or bona fide bid or asked prices, they list the degree of control represented by the block as a valuation factor. (Rev. Rul. 93-12, 1993-1 C.B. 202, Law and Analysis, quoting Treas. Reg. § 25.2512-2(a), (f).)

That factor relates to the family aggregation question. If the block being valued is treated as part of a larger family-held controlling interest, its degree of control may be viewed differently than if the block is valued by itself.

The question presented

The issue was whether the Service could treat shares held by a donor’s family members as if they were held together with the transferred shares. That would mean valuing a block that is a minority interest on its own as part of a controlling interest because of the family relationship.

Rev. Rul. 81-253 had taken a position that Rev. Rul. 93-12 revoked. The 1993 ruling explains the change by reference to four decisions that, as described in the ruling, did not assume all family-held voting power could be aggregated.

The facts described in the ruling

The ruling gives an example: a donor identified as P transferred five 20-percent interests in a corporation to P’s children. (Rev. Rul. 93-12, 1993-1 C.B. 202, Facts.)

The holding

The ruling reaches several connected conclusions.

  1. Valuation without regard to family relationship. In the stated example, the five 20-percent interests transferred by P to P’s children should be valued without regard to the parties’ family relationship. (Rev. Rul. 93-12, 1993-1 C.B. 202, Facts, Holding.)
  2. No aggregation of family shares in the single-class setting. For a corporation with a single class of stock, other family members’ shares are not aggregated with the transferred shares to decide whether the transferred shares should be valued as part of a controlling interest. (Rev. Rul. 93-12, 1993-1 C.B. 202, Law and Analysis.)
  3. Service position on the cited cases. For estate and gift tax valuation, the Service will follow Bright, Propstra, Andrews, and Lee without assuming that all family-held voting power can be aggregated to decide whether transferred shares are part of a controlling interest. (Rev. Rul. 93-12, 1993-1 C.B. 202, Holding.)
  4. Minority discount not disallowed solely because of family aggregation. A minority discount will not be disallowed solely because the transferred interest, aggregated with family members’ interests, would be part of a controlling interest. The ruling says this applies whether the donor held all or a lesser percentage of the stock immediately before the gift. (Rev. Rul. 93-12, 1993-1 C.B. 202, Holding.)

The word “solely” matters. The ruling removes family relationship as a stand-alone reason to disallow a minority discount. It does not say a discount must be allowed or address what other facts could affect the valuation.

Effect on other documents

The ruling revoked Rev. Rul. 81-253. It also substituted acquiescence for nonacquiescence in issue one of Lee. (Rev. Rul. 93-12, 1993-1 C.B. 202, Effect on Other Documents.)

What the ruling does not do

Rev. Rul. 93-12 has clear limits.

  • No discount amount. The ruling does not state or quantify any discount or reduction in value.
  • No guarantee. The ruling does not promise that a minority discount will be available. It addresses only whether family relationship by itself permits aggregation or disallowance.
  • Single class of stock. The ruling’s statement about non-aggregation is framed for a corporation with a single class of stock.
  • No valuation method. The ruling does not supply a formula, an appraisal method, or a rule for every gift or estate tax situation. Value remains a question of facts and applicable law under the willing buyer and willing seller standard.
  • Current status. Readers may wish to ask a qualified professional to verify the ruling’s current status and how later law may bear on a given transfer.

Hypothetical example

Hypothetical example. The figures below are illustrative only. They are not drawn from the ruling and do not show a discount amount or tax result.

A parent holds all outstanding stock of a closely held corporation with a single class of voting common stock. In one year, the parent gives a 25-percent block to each of four children.

Before Rev. Rul. 93-12, one possible argument was that the four blocks, all held within one family, should be treated together as a controlling interest. Under the ruling’s approach, family relationship by itself would not be a basis for that aggregation. Each 25-percent block would be valued on its own, using the willing buyer and willing seller standard and the factors described in the regulations, including the degree of control the block represents.

Now change one fact. The parent held only part of the stock before the gifts, and a sibling held the rest. The ruling says its holding on minority discounts applies whether the donor held all or a lesser percentage of the stock immediately before the gift. Family relationship alone would again not be the reason to disallow a minority discount.

In both versions, the ruling does not say whether a discount applies or how large it would be. Those questions depend on the facts, evidence, appraisal, and law in effect for the transfer. The ruling does not address other facts that could bear on value, and this example does not either.

Questions a reader may take to a CPA or tax attorney

  • Does the corporation in question have a single class of stock, and if not, how might that affect whether the reasoning of Rev. Rul. 93-12 is relevant?
  • Has Rev. Rul. 93-12 been modified, clarified, or affected by later statutes, regulations, rulings, or court decisions that bear on this transfer?
  • Apart from family relationship, what facts could affect how the degree of control of the transferred block is assessed?
  • What appraisal standards and documentation would a qualified appraiser use to support a valuation under Treas. Reg. § 25.2512-1 and § 25.2512-2?
  • How do Bright, Propstra, Andrews, and Lee compare with the facts of this transfer, and how have later courts read them?
  • Does the transfer raise gift tax and estate tax issues that may need to be analyzed separately?
  • What are the potential consequences if the IRS disagrees with a reported value?

Sources

This page is general research, not tax, legal, or investment advice. Do not take any action based on this page without first consulting a qualified CPA or tax attorney who knows your facts.