Text or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260

Tax Law

Connelly v. United States (2024): life insurance in redemption buy-sell agreements

In Connelly v. United States, the Supreme Court held that, on its facts, a corporation's obligation to redeem a decedent's shares at fair market value did not offset corporate life insurance proceeds, which increased the shares' federal estate tax value. The Court did not hold that every redemption obligation is disregarded (Slip op. at 5-9 and n.2).

This page is general research, not tax, legal, or investment advice. Do not take any action based on this page without first consulting a qualified CPA or tax attorney who knows your facts.

Case facts2024

Status of the decision

ItemDetailPinpoint cite
CaseConnelly v. United States, No. 23-146Slip op. at 1
Date decidedJune 6, 2024Slip op. at 1
DispositionThe Court affirmed the Eighth CircuitSlip op. at 1, Syllabus at 3
Form of sourceSlip opinion, subject to formal revision before publication in the United States ReportsNotice preceding slip op. at 1

Why the case matters to closely held businesses

Owners of closely held corporations sometimes enter into buy-sell agreements that govern what happens to an owner's shares at death. In a redemption structure, the corporation agrees to buy back, or redeem, the shares of a deceased owner. Corporate-owned life insurance is often used to fund that obligation.

Connelly addressed a valuation question that arises under this kind of arrangement. When a corporation receives life insurance proceeds on an owner's death and is obligated to use those proceeds to redeem the owner's shares, does the redemption obligation cancel out the proceeds when the shares are valued for federal estate tax purposes? The Court answered no on the facts before it.

The decision is relevant to the study of how redemption agreements and corporate-owned life insurance interact with estate tax valuation. It does not determine the outcome for any other agreement, insurance arrangement, or set of facts.

Facts of the case

The opinion describes a closely held corporation owned by two brothers. The corporation held life insurance policies of $3.5 million on each brother, which it intended to use to fund a redemption of a deceased brother's shares (Syllabus at 1-2, Slip op. at 3-4).

After one brother died, the corporation received insurance proceeds and used $3 million to redeem the decedent's shares. The decedent held a 77.18% interest in the corporation. The Internal Revenue Service took the position that the insurance proceeds used for the redemption should be counted in the corporation's value and assessed additional estate tax of $889,914 (Syllabus at 1-2, Slip op. at 3-4).

These figures describe this case. They are not current tax rates, thresholds, limits, or deadlines, and they do not represent a general valuation formula.

The question presented

The central issue was whether a corporation's contractual obligation to redeem shares is a liability that reduces the corporation's value for federal estate tax purposes, offsetting life insurance proceeds earmarked for the redemption so they do not increase the value of the decedent's shares (Syllabus at 2, Slip op. at 9).

What the Court held

The Court's reasoning can be summarized in four steps.

1. Share value must reflect corporate fair market value. Federal estate tax valuation of a decedent's shares in a closely held corporation must reflect the corporation's fair market value. Life insurance proceeds payable to the corporation are an asset that increases that fair market value (Slip op. at 5-6).

2. A redemption obligation is not necessarily a liability. A corporation's contractual obligation to redeem shares is not necessarily a liability that reduces the corporation's value for federal estate tax purposes (Syllabus at 2, Slip op. at 9).

3. A fair market value redemption did not reduce share value here. In Connelly, the obligation to redeem shares at fair market value did not offset the insurance proceeds committed to fund the redemption. On these facts, a redemption at fair market value did not reduce the value of the decedent's shares (Slip op. at 5-7, 9).

4. Valuation is measured at death, before the proceeds are spent. Estate tax valuation concerns the value of the decedent's property at death, before the corporation spent the proceeds on the redemption. The Court reasoned that a hypothetical buyer would treat the insurance proceeds used for the redemption as a net asset in the circumstances described (Slip op. at 7-8).

Case illustration drawn from the opinion

The following illustration uses figures reported in the opinion. It is not hypothetical. These amounts are case-specific facts, not general rules.

ComponentCase figurePinpoint cite
Insurance proceeds used for the redemption$3 millionSyllabus at 1-2, Slip op. at 3-4, 6
Other corporate value$3.86 millionSlip op. at 6
Total corporate value, as the Court treated it$6.86 millionSlip op. at 6
Decedent's ownership interest77.18%Slip op. at 3-4, 6
Approximate value of decedent's sharesabout $5.3 millionSlip op. at 6
Additional estate tax assessed$889,914Syllabus at 1-2, Slip op. at 4

The arithmetic follows the Court's framing. Adding the $3 million in insurance proceeds to $3.86 million in other value yields $6.86 million. A 77.18% interest in $6.86 million is approximately $5.3 million. Under the position the Court rejected, the redemption obligation would have offset the proceeds, leaving a lower corporate value. The Court instead included the proceeds in value at the moment of death (Slip op. at 5-8).

This illustration does not show how any other agreement, policy structure, or ownership split would be valued.

What the Court did not decide

The opinion is limited in several respects.

  • Not every redemption obligation is ignored. The Court stated that it did not hold that a redemption obligation can never decrease a corporation's value. It observed that an obligation requiring the liquidation of operating assets could reduce future earning capacity. The Court rejected the broader position that all redemption obligations reduce net value (Slip op. at 9 n.2).
  • Insurance proceeds do not always increase share value in every circumstance. The holding turned on the facts presented, including a redemption at fair market value funded by proceeds payable to the corporation (Slip op. at 5-9).
  • Agreement prices and outside valuations are not the Court's method. The opinion should not be read as adopting the parties' agreement price, or any valuation prepared for them, as a general valuation method.
  • Other structures and terms were not before the Court. The decision does not establish the outcome for different agreement terms, insurance ownership arrangements, or facts beyond the limited holding.

The cross-purchase alternative

The Court identified a cross-purchase agreement as an alternative arrangement. In general terms, a cross-purchase agreement is one under which the owners, rather than the corporation, agree to buy a deceased owner's interest. The Court also noted that this alternative has its own drawbacks and tax consequences (Slip op. at 8-9).

The opinion does not describe a cross-purchase structure as a way to reduce or defer estate tax in every case, and it does not compare outcomes across structures in detail. Evaluating a cross-purchase arrangement or restructuring an existing redemption agreement involves facts and considerations beyond the decision.

Research observations

Several observations follow from the opinion without predicting a particular result.

  • Owners and advisers studying redemption agreements funded by corporate-owned life insurance may wish to examine how the insurance proceeds would be reflected in corporate value at death, in light of the Court's reasoning (Slip op. at 5-8).
  • The Court's footnote suggests that the effect of a redemption obligation may depend on how the obligation would be satisfied, including whether operating assets would need to be liquidated (Slip op. at 9 n.2).
  • The decision addresses federal estate tax valuation. It does not resolve other tax questions that a buy-sell arrangement may raise.

No part of the decision guarantees a tax result for any buy-sell arrangement.

Questions to take to a CPA or tax attorney

  1. Is an existing buy-sell agreement structured as a redemption, a cross-purchase, or a hybrid, and how might the reasoning in Connelly bear on its estate tax valuation?
  2. Who owns and is the beneficiary of any life insurance intended to fund the agreement, and how might the proceeds be reflected in corporate value at death?
  3. Would satisfying a redemption obligation require the liquidation of operating assets, and is the footnote in Connelly (Slip op. at 9 n.2) relevant to those facts?
  4. What drawbacks and tax consequences might apply if a cross-purchase arrangement were considered as an alternative?
  5. Have any authorities issued after June 6, 2024 interpreted or applied Connelly in ways that matter for the specific agreement?
  6. How do the agreement's price terms relate to fair market value as the Court described it, and what documentation might support a valuation position?

This page is general research, not tax, legal, or investment advice. Do not take any action based on this page without first consulting a qualified CPA or tax attorney who knows your facts.

Sources

  1. Connelly v. United States, No. 23-146, slip opinion (U.S. June 6, 2024). https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/23-146_i42j.pdf
    • Syllabus at 1-2: case facts, including insurance policies, redemption amount, and additional tax assessed.
    • Syllabus at 2 and Opinion of the Court at 9: a redemption obligation is not necessarily a liability that reduces corporate value.
    • Syllabus at 3 and Opinion of the Court at 1: affirmance of the Eighth Circuit.
    • Opinion of the Court at 3-4, 6: ownership percentage, corporate value components, and share value.
    • Opinion of the Court at 5-6: share valuation must reflect corporate fair market value, and insurance proceeds are a corporate asset.
    • Opinion of the Court at 5-7, 9: fair market value redemption did not offset the insurance proceeds on these facts.
    • Opinion of the Court at 7-8: valuation measured at death, before proceeds were spent, from the perspective of a hypothetical buyer.
    • Opinion of the Court at 8-9: cross-purchase agreement as an alternative, with its own drawbacks and tax consequences.
    • Opinion of the Court at 9 n.2: the Court did not hold that a redemption obligation can never decrease corporate value.